Appeal Brief | Appeal Letter | Appeal Analysis | Back
Second Appeal Brief
PA ID# 003-32272-00; City of Gulf Shores
PW ID# 792; Engineered Beach Sand Replacement
FEMA-1605-DR-AL; City of Gulf Shores, Engineered Beach Sand Replacement, Project Worksheet (PW) 792
Work Eligibility; Debris Removal and Disposal
Hurricane Katrina eroded 710,000 CY of sand from the engineered beaches in Gulf Shores. PW 792 was prepared to replace this sand with sand dredged from offshore, and sand recovered from public rights of way and private property, after it was agreed that removal of the landward sand was necessary as a health and safety hazard. It was more effective to return this sand to the beach than to remove and dispose of it as debris. The Applicant replaced 935,653 CY of sand with the excess coming from the landward sources. The PW closeout version and the first appeal response reduced the landward sand quantities to get to an eligible amount of sand replacement. The second appeal requested that all of the landward sand be eligible with the Applicants being responsible for the excess dredged sand. Other associated costs were requested to also be adjusted accordingly.
Are the additional 225,653 cubic yards of sand that the Applicant placed on the beach eligible for reimbursement?
44 CFR §§206.224 and 206.226(j)