Unit VI: Explosive Blast Unit VI COURSE TITLE Building Design for Homeland Security TIME 60 minutes UNIT TITLE Explosive Blast OBJECTIVES 1. Explain the basic physics involved during an explosive blast event, whether by terrorism or technological accident 1. 2. Explain building damage and personnel injury resulting from the blast effects upon a building 2. 3. Perform an initial prediction of blast loading and effects based upon incident pressure SCOPE The following topics will be covered in this unit: 1. 1. Time-pressure regions of a blast event and how these change with distance from the blast 2. 2. Difference between incident pressure and reflected pressure 3. 3. Differences between peak pressure and peak impulse and how these differences affect building components 4. 4. Building damage and personal injuries generated by blast wave effects 5. 5. Levels of protection used by the Department of Defense and the General Services Administration 6. 6. The nominal range-to-effect chart [minimum stand-off in feet versus weapon yield in pounds of TNT-equivalent] for an identified level of damage or injury 7. 7. The benefits of stand-off distance 8. 8. Approaches to predicting blast loads and effects, including one using incident pressure Unit VI REFERENCES 1. FEMA 426, Reference Manual to Mitigate Potential Terrorist Attacks Against Buildings, pages 4-1 to 4-20 1. 2. Student Manual, Unit VI 2. 3. Case Study, Hazardville Information Company (HIC), for student activities 3. 4. Unit VI visuals REQUIREMENTS 1. FEMA 426, Reference Manual to Mitigate Potential Terrorist Attacks Against Buildings (one per student) 1. 2. Instructor Guide 2. 3. Student Manual (one per student) 3. 4. Overhead projector or computer display unit 4. 5. Unit VI visuals 5. 6. Chart paper, easel, and markers UNIT VI OUTLINE Time Page VI. Explosive Blast 60 minutes IG VI-1 1. 1. Introduction and Unit Overview 5 minutes IG VI-4 2. 2. Blast Characteristics and Their Interaction with Buildings 15 minutes IG VI-4 3. 3. Types of Building Damage and Personal Injuries Caused 10 minutes IG VI-11 by Blast Effects 4. 4. Levels of Protection Used by Federal Agencies 5 minutes IG VI-15 5. 5. The Nominal Range-to-Effect Chart and Benefits of Stand-5 minutes IG VI-16 off 6. 6. Predicting Blast Loads and Effects 5 minutes IG VI-20 7. 7. Activity: Stand-off Distance and the Effects of Blast 15 minutes IG VI-24 PREPARING TO TEACH THIS UNIT . Ą Tailoring Content to the Local Area: Review the Instructor Notes to identify topics that should focus on the local area. Plan how you will use the generic content, and prepare for a locally oriented discussion. . Ą Optional Activity: There are no optional activities in this unit. Unit VI . Ą Activity: The students will begin have an instructor led exercise to use the range-to-effects chart, select a Level of Protection, and use the effects charts to evaluate stand-off distances. . Ą Refer students to their Student Manuals for worksheets and activities. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-1 Introduction and Unit Overview This is Unit VI Explosive Blast. Note that we are covering pages 4-1 to 4-20 in FEMA 426 during this unit. In the previous units, we determined the various initial ratings during the assessment process. In this unit, we will examine how explosive blast impacts buildings and people to better understand the design recommendations presented in later units. VISUAL VI-2 Unit Objectives At the end of this unit, you should be able to: 1. 1. Explain the basic physics involved during an explosive blast event, whether by terrorism or technological accident. 2. 2. Explain building damage and personnel injury resulting from the blast effects upon a building. 3. 3. Perform an initial prediction of blast loading and effects based upon incident pressure. VISUAL VI-3 Explosive Blast There are a number of similarities between blast loading and building response with earthquake or high wind loading and response, but also significant differences. Blast loads are high amplitude, low duration (milliseconds) events that create an air pressure wave that acts over the entire building envelope. Earthquake loads are usually low amplitude,Many of the mitigation options for seismic long duration (seconds) events that areand hurricane retrofit such as moment transferred through the foundation. High Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY connections and elimination of progressive winds are dynamic and typically affect the collapse, laminated glass, and strengthened envelope. architectural elements mitigate many explosive blast vulnerabilities. Blast loadings decay as a cube root of distance; therefore, the key concept in blast is: STAND-OFF IS YOUR BEST DEFENSE, EVERY FOOT COUNTS! VISUAL VI-4 Blast Loading Factors Explosive properties type - is it a high explosive or low-order explosive? Is it specifically designed for the purpose military grade explosive (C4, landmine, etc.) or a combination of generally available materials (ANFO, black powder)? The energy output of explosives can be related by TNT equivalency. TNT equivalency is usually considered to be the relative pressure achieved by the explosive compared to TNT (trinitrotoluene). Pressure equivalency can generally range from 0.14 to 1.7. Aside from TNT equivalency, the larger the quantity of an explosive, the higher the pressures and the larger the impulse. VISUAL VI-5 Typical Incident Pressure Waveform Typical Incident Pressure Waveform The explosive detonation generates a bubble of air moving at supersonic speed from the bomb location. About one-third of the explosive material contributes to the detonation. As it reaches a point in space, such as a person or building, the pressure goes rapidly from atmospheric to peak pressure in very little Figure 4-3: Typical Impulse Waveform, page 4-4 time. The pressure at this point decays rapidly BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-5 as the supersonic bubble moves on, its pressure reducing exponentially as the surface Exam Questions #A8 and B6 area of the bubble increases - expending energy over an ever increasing area. The Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY There is also a TNT equivalency based upon pressure also drops off due to the completion impulse and that ranges from 0.5 to 1.8. If of the chemical reaction of the explosive the pressure TNT equivalency is above 1.0, mixture (burning of the remaining two-thirds this means the explosive achieves a higher of the material). If the explosion occurs within pressure (pressure equivalency) than TNT. If a confined space, the gases generated by the the impulse TNT equivalency is above 1.0, burning of the explosive are contained and then the explosive has a longer push keep the pressure elevated over a longer (impulse equivalency) than TNT. period of time. [Indicate a longer tail off of the positive phase to illustrate the confined space . Ą Peak pressure rapid millisecond rise variation.] Design is typically based on . Ą High positive pressure loading drops off positive pressures. . Ą Negative pressure creates suction on the structure The negative phase of the blast wave is the ambient air rushing in behind the blast wave to return to a stable pressure. While the negative phase has much less energy than the positive phase, it can hit the structure at the most inopportune moment in its vibration, resulting in unexpected consequences - increased damage or having windows blow OUT of the building rather than into it. Design is based on positive pressure. VISUAL VI-6 Reflected Pressure versus Angle of Incident Reflected Pressure/Angle of Incidence When the blast wave strikes an immovable surface the wave reflects off the surface resulting in an increase in pressure. This reflected pressure actually causes the damage to the building. A very high reflected pressure may punch a hole in a wall or cause a column to fail, while a low reflected pressure will try to push over the whole building. The worst case is when the direction of travel BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-6 for the blast wave is perpendicular to the surface of the structure and the incident pressure is very high. The Coefficient of Reflection can be from 12 to 13 for high incident pressures in this case. By keeping the incident pressure low (by limiting the size of the explosive, maintaining a large distance between the explosive and the building, or both) the reflected pressure can be Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY kept low. Keeping the Coefficient of Reflection below 2.5 by keeping the peak incident pressure below 5 psi (pounds per square inch) is a desirable goal. VISUAL VI-7 Incident and Reflected Pressure When the incident pressure wave impinges on a structure that is not parallel to the direction of the wave's travel, it is reflected and reinforced. The reflected pressure is always greater than the incident pressure at the same distance from the explosion, and varies with the incident angle. VISUAL VI-8 Typical Blast Impulse Waveform Typical Blast Impulse Waveform Another consideration is the impulse of the blast wave, which is the integration of the peak incident pressure (both positive phase and negative phase) at the point in question over time. A general rule of thumb is that brittle materials respond to peak incident pressure and are less affected by impulse. Ductile materials, on the other hand, respond more to BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-8 impulse (the total push) rather than peak incident pressure (the maximum hit). Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-9 Blast Loading Factors Location Relative to Structure: Stand-off distance is your best friend. The larger the distance between the explosive and the structure, the lower the incident pressure and the lower the resultant reflective pressure. We will investigate this in more detail later. As we have already seen, the reflection angle at which the blast wave strikes the structure also affects the value of reflected pressure. The ground is also a reflection surface to consider. If the bomb is placed close to the ground, the ground reflection adds a small amount of incident pressure to the situation. If the bomb is elevated (a more difficult task), the ground reflection can become significant, but the reflection off the building surface diminishes. Identifying the worst case situation begins by finding the closest approach (stand-off distance) between the explosive and the building and then considering the angle of reflection. Or put another way -- place the explosive directly perpendicular to the largest face of the building, with the explosive centered upon the building's face as close as you can get. That is normally the worst case situation. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-10 Blast Compared to Natural Hazards (1) Compared to other hazards (earthquake, winds, and floods), high order explosive attack has unique variances: . Ą Compared to wind, explosive blast pressure is much higher, but also of much shorter duration and, thus, lower impulse. . Ą High explosives generate high pressures but the impulse lasts for a relatively short duration (in the range of milliseconds). . Ą Low-order explosives generate less pressure, but the impulse lasts longer than high explosive (in the range of milliseconds). . Ą Wind has a very low incident pressure, but pushes for a very long time (in the range of seconds or longer). . Ą A nuclear blast or millions of pounds of high explosives would generate high pressures AND long duration impulse. VISUAL VI-11 Blast Compared to Natural Hazards (2) Explosive blast tends to cause localized damage compared to other hazards that may destroy the whole building. . Ą The first building surface struck will get the greatest pressures, and expect it to receive the greatest damage. The blast may break a building component by punching through it (window or wall) or shearing it (column). . Ą The other side of the building, due to its greater distance from the explosion, will see lower pressures, unless there are nearby buildings that will reflect the blast wave back to the building in question. . Ą Reflections can increase damage to the building, but are hard to quantify. . Ą Greater mass has usually been the design Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY of choice to protect against explosive blast. The inertia of the mass slows the structural reactions to the point that the impulse is over before the building tends to move. Ą Conversely, additional mass is usually undesirable during an earthquake due to the long duration, low frequency forces that can get the mass moving. Earthquake design usually concentrates on lighter structures with great ductility and additional reinforcement at weak points. VISUAL VI-12 Factors Contributing to Building Damage Certain prediction of damage to buildings and people during an explosive event is beyond the scope of the reference manual. There are too many variables that would have to be considered and modeling would take many months for analysis by supercomputer. Thus, as in standard building design, we use approaches with safety factors that provide adequate first approximations to estimate response based upon the: . Ą The amount of explosive usually expressed as TNT equivalent weight. . Ą The stand-off distance between the explosive and the building or person. Ą Assumptions about building characteristics - the exterior envelope construction (walls and windows) and the framing or load-bearing system used. . Ą The building characteristics provide insight into weaknesses and allow general predictions about how the building will respond. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-13 Types of Building Damage . Ą The air blast, especially from explosions close to the building, results in component failure of walls, windows, columns, and beams/girders. . Ą The pressures experienced by the building can far exceed the building's original design and can occur in directions that were not part of the original design. . Ą Once the exterior envelope is breached, the blast wave causes additional structural and non-structural damage inside the building. Exam Questions #A9 and B10 Ą Collapse, which is covered in more detail in Chapter 3 of FEMA 426, is a primary cause of death and injury in an explosive blast. . Ą Localized collapse may have a load-bearing wall, or portion thereof, on one side of the building fall to the ground or a single column fails and the surrounding floors fall with it. . Ą Progressive collapse is more disastrous as a single component failure, like a wall or column, results in the failure of more walls and columns so that more of the building falls to the ground than what the explosive initially affected. VISUAL VI-14 Blast Pressure Effects Frame 1 Blast Pressure Effects . Ą The air blast strikes the exterior wall, the weakest component will fail first - usually the windows, which saves the walls and columns, but causes much non-structural damage inside the building. . Ą Note that unreinforced masonry walls can be weaker than windows. . Ą If the explosive is close enough, the walls can fail and one or more columns can fail BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-14 in addition to the windows. Ą Based upon the reflection angle, one can Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY expect the lowest or lower floors (1 to 3) to receive the greatest damage. Ą If the blast wave strikes the whole surface of the exposed side simultaneously, this is called a laminar situation, and breaching (puncture) of walls and failure of columns is less likely. VISUAL VI-15 Blast Pressure Effects Frame 2 Blast Pressure Effects Ą Once the blast wave enters the building, it is trapped and more air enters the building, further increasing the pressure. Structural components like flooring and shear walls now are moving in directions for which they were not designed. Ą Floor failure can result in three effects: 1) the raining down of concrete chunks causing injury and possibly death; 2) the whole floor gives way and pancakes BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-15 downward with obviously more serious consequences; or 3) if flat slab construction was used (the floors act as the beams in the framing system), the floors can disconnect from the columns. VISUAL VI-16 Blast Pressure Effects Frame 3 Blast Pressure Effects . Ą The blast wave continues to engulf the building. Any building component that traps the blast wave, like an overhanging roof, can expect increased damage, based upon how it is constructed and attached. . Ą The roof and sides parallel to the blast wave movement will see incident pressure only, which should result in little or no damage. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-16 Ą Once the blast wave has passed the building, the far side (opposite the side first experiencing the blast wave) will see increased pressure as a slight vacuum forms and the ambient air rushes back in to Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY most effective way to reduce injuries during explosive blast is harden the glass and window frame system and/or reduce the amount of glass. VISUAL VI-19 Murrah Federal Building (1) The Murrah Federal Building is typical of many commercial properties in the current inventory. The bomb was designed as a shape charge and detonated in the drop-off area, destroying two primary columns and causing the spandrel beam to rotate. The floors above failed in progressive collapse and the blast wave penetrated deeply into the interior. VISUAL VI-20 Murrah Federal Building (2) The majority of deaths were caused by the collapsing structure. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY glass is the weakest component of the building envelope. Conversely, the columns, whether concrete or steel, are usually the strongest components of the building envelope. [A workable rule of thumb is that steel columns require about twice the stand-off distance compared to concrete columns for the same weapon yield.] Ą Ask what the threshold of concrete column failure stand-off distance is for a 300pound bomb? ANSWER: Approximately 25 feet. VISUAL VI-25 Comparison of Stand-off The Murrah Federal Building and Khobar Towers blasts vividly illustrate the response of a building to a blast event. The Murrah Federal Building had less than 20 feet of stand-off and was not designed to prevent progressive collapse. Khobar Towers was designed using British code to prevent progressive collapse and had approximately 80 feet of stand-off distance. Notice the size of the weapons. The Murrah Federal Building was unsalvageable and demolished, while Khobar Towers only lost the front faŤade and was quickly restored and placed back into service. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-28 Cost versus Stand-off Cost Versus Stand-off Ą As in any design for new construction or renovation, there are trade-offs that must be considered. While increasing the distance between the closest approaches of a vehicle bomb to the building is highly desirable, it is not without a cost. Ą The increased distance means more land is needed, which may require considerable time and expense to acquire. The increased land also means a larger perimeter BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-28 boundary that then requires more perimeter fencing, landscaping, vehicle barriers, lighting, closed-circuit television, etc. Thus, while the increased stand-off allows a less expensive building to be constructed, there are other costs that must be considered in the overall project. . Ą Where stand-off distance cannot be increased, building hardening is usually necessary to achieve the same level of protection against the Design Basis Threat weapon yield. As the stand-off distance decreases, the cost of hardening significantly increases because the building must now withstand damage that it would not experience at higher standoff. . Ą Consider progressive collapse. At large stand-off distance, the design of the building framing and columns should meet basic design to prevent progressive collapse. This would be for the loss of one column, for example. At smaller stand-off distances, the columns may require additional hardening to prevent the failure of more than one column during an explosive blast event. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-29 Blast Load Predictions . Ą The first step in designing a building for explosive blast is to understand the pressures and impulses the building may experience during the potential blast event. If reflections are a concern, then high-level software, such as Computational Fluid Dynamics, may be in order. As a first effort, simpler software, such as ATBLAST and CONWEP, can give a prediction of incident blast loading values and a prediction for reflected pressure and impulse using simplifying assumptions. . Ą Pressure versus distance (Figure 4-10 in FEMA 426, page 4-17) is another method for predicting the incident pressure as shown in the next slide. VISUAL VI-30 Pressure versus Distance Pressure Ą Figure 4-10 breaks the blast load estimate into the essential elements of weapon yield versus or explosive weight in TNT equivalent on Distance the x-axis and stand-off distance on the y-axis to give an incident pressure value that a building can experience. Ą Note that the x-axis is logarithmic and the y-axis is linear. If both axes were logarithmic as used on the range-to-effect Figure 4-10: Incident Overpressure Measured in Pounds Per Sq. Inch, as a Function of Stand-Off Distance and Net Explosive Weight, page 4-17, FEMA 426 chart presented earlier, the curves of this BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VI-30 chart would be straight lines. In other words, on a log-log scale of explosive Direct students' attention to Figure 4-10, weight and stand-off distance, a straight page 4-17 of FEMA 426 line indicates a pressure relationship (not impulse). Ą Ask what stand-off distance is required for a 300-pound bomb to keep the incident pressure at 1.0 psi or lower. ANSWER: Approximately 250 feet. Incident Level of Protection Pressure (psi) High 1.2 Medium 1.9 Low 2.3 Very Low 3.5 Below AT Standards > 3.5 Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VI-33 Summary . Ą You now have an understanding of the basic physics involved during an explosive blast event. . Ą You can now explain building damage and injury to people resulting from the blast effects upon a building and injury to people in the open. . Ą You can perform an initial prediction of blast loading and effects based upon incident pressure using a nominal range-to-effect chart or the incident pressure charts. VISUAL VI-34 Student Activity This activity provides a check on learning about explosive blast. Activity Requirements Working in small groups, refer to FEMA 426 and complete the worksheet questions. After 15 minutes, solutions will be reviewed in plenary group. Refer participants to FEMA 426 and the Unit VI Case Study activity in the Student Manual. Members of the instructor staff should be available to answer questions and assist groups as needed. At the end of 15 minutes, reconvene the class and facilitate group reporting. Unit VI: Explosive Blast INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY Transition Unit VII will cover CBR measures and introduce the basic science needed to understand building protection against chemical, biological, and radiological agents, and complete the assessment and analysis units. Unit VIII will begin the process of reviewing the site, layout, and building design guidance and evaluation of mitigation options. Unit VI: Explosive Blast UNIT VI CASE STUDY ACTIVITY: STAND-OFF DISTANCE AND THE EFFECTS OF BLAST The requirements in this Unit's activity are intended to provide a check on learning about explosive blast. Requirement 1. 1. In the empty cells in the table below, identify whether the adjacent description defines incident pressure or reflected pressure. . 2. Refer to Figure 4-5 in FEMA 426 (page 4-11) to answer the following questions regarding the explosives environment: . Ą What is the minimum stand-off distance from a 100-pound bomb explosion to eliminate the danger of glass breakage and severe wounds (without fragment retention film)? 400 feet . Ą What damage will be sustained at 400 feet from a 5,000-pound bomb explosion? Wall fragment injuries or injuries to personnel in the open . 3. Refer to Figure 4-10 and Table 4-3 (pages 4-17 and 4-19, respectively) in FEMA 426 to answer the following questions regarding the explosives environment. . Ą What is the minimum stand-off required to limit the incident pressure to under 0.5 psi for a 100-pound bomb? Approximately 325 feet . Ą What incident pressure would be expected at 500 feet from a 500-pound bomb and what is the approximate damage? Approximately 0.75 psi, minor damage to some buildings Definition Type of Pressure Characterized by an almost instantaneous rise Incident pressure from atmospheric pressure to peak overpressure. When it impinges on a structure that is not Reflective Pressure parallel to the direction of the wave's travel, the pressure wave is reflected and reinforced. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures Unit VII COURSE TITLE Building Design for Homeland Security TIME 60 minutes UNIT TITLE Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures OBJECTIVES 1. Explain the five possible protective actions for a building and its occupants 1. 2. Compare filtration and collection mechanisms and applicability to the particles present in chemical, biological, and radiological agents 2. 3. Explain the key issues with CBR detection 3. 4. Identify the indications of CBR contamination SCOPE The following topics will be covered in this unit: 1. 1. Five protective actions for a building and its occupants: evacuation; sheltering in place; personal protective equipment; air filtration and pressurization; and exhausting and purging 2. 2. Air filtration and cleaning principles and its application 3. 3. CBR detection technology currently available 4. 4. Indications of CBR contamination that do not use technology REFERENCES The following sources will provide information used in this Unit: 1. 1. FEMA 426, Reference Manual to Mitigate Potential Terrorist Attacks Against Buildings, pages 5-1 to 5-36 2. 2. Appendix C, Chemical, Biological, and Radiological Glossary 3. 3. Student Manual, Unit VII 4. 4. Case Study - Hazardville Information Company 5. 5. Unit VII visuals REQUIREMENTS 1. FEMA 426, Reference Manual to Mitigate Potential Terrorist Attacks Against Buildings (one per student) 1. 2. Instructor Guide 2. 3. Student Manual (one per student) 3. 4. Overhead projector or computer display unit 4. 5. Unit VII visuals 5. 6. Chart paper, easel, and markers Unit VII UNIT VII OUTLINE Time Page VII. CBR Measures 60 minutes IG VII-4 1. 1. Protective Actions for Buildings and Occupants 15 minutes IG VII-4 2. 2. CBR Detection and Technology 15 minutes IG VII-16 3. 3. Air Filtration and Cleaning Principles and Technology 20 minutes IG VII-23 4. 4. Activity: CBR Considerations 10 minutes IG VII-32 WRITTEN EXAM 1 hour Exam 30 minutes Feedback 30 minutes PREPARING TO TEACH THIS UNIT Ą Tailoring Content to the Local Area: Review the Instructor Notes to identify topics that may focus on the local area. Plan how you will use the generic content, and prepare for a locally oriented discussion. As with Unit VI, the Instructor for this unit will present the characteristics of CBR agents and how a building can be operated or built to reduce the effects of these agents. The principles of air filtration and cleaning and how to apply this equipment are issues to cover in building design. Similarly, the current technology for detecting CBR agents is another building design and operation issue. Finally, the Instructor covers non-technology indications of CBR contamination. . Ą Optional Activity: There are no optional activities in this unit. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-1 BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII Chemical, Biological, andRadiological (CBR)Measures VISUAL VII-2 Unit Objectives Explain the five possible protective actions for a building and its occupants. Compare filtration and collection mechanisms and applicability to the particles present in chemical, biological, and radiological agents. Explain the key issues with CBR detection. Identify the indicators of CBR contamination. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-2 Introduction and Unit Overview This is Unit VII CBR Measures. In this Unit, CBR protective measures and actions to safeguard the occupants of a building from CBR threats are presented. The Unit is based largely on CDC/NIOSH and DoD guidance. Unit Objectives At the end of this Unit, the participant should be able to: 1. 1. Explain the five possible protective actions for a building and its occupants. 2. 2. Compare filtration and collection mechanisms and applicability to the particles present in chemical, biological, and radiological agents. 3. 3. Explain the key issues with CBR detection. 4. 4. Identify the indications of CBR contamination. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-3 Unit VII: CBR Measures Units I-V discussed Assessments - Risk. Units VI and VII explain Blast and CBR Weapons and effects. Units VIII and IX demonstrate techniques for site layout and building design to counter or mitigate manmade threats. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-3 VISUAL VII-4 CBR Measures: An Overview FEMA 426, Chapter 5 is based on best practices for safeguarding building occupants from CBR threats. This module is organized into four sections : . Ą Protective Actions for Buildings and Occupants . Ą Air Filtration and Cleaning Principles and Technology . Ą CBR Detection and Technology . Ą Non-Technology CBR Contamination Indications BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-4 CBR Measures This unit is based on guidance from the CDC/NIOSH and the DoD and presents protective measures and actions to safeguard the occupants of a building from CBR threats. Evacuation, sheltering in place, personal protective equipment, air filtration and pressurization, and exhausting and purging will be discussed, as well as CBR detection. Additionally, CBR design mitigation measures are discussed in Chapter 3 of FEMA 426 and Appendix C of FEMA 426 contains a glossary of CBR terms and a summary of CBR agent characteristics. Recent terrorist events have increased interest in the vulnerability of buildings to CBR threats. Of particular concern are building HVAC systems, because they can become an entry point and distribution system for airborne hazardous contaminants. Even without special protective systems, buildings can provide protection in varying degrees against airborne hazards that originate outdoors. CBR Measures: FEMA 426 Chapter 5 Overview This Unit draws on the latest research from CDC/NIOSH to present the best practices for detecting CBR agents, and safeguarding building occupants from the effects of CBR contamination. The FEMA 426 chapter on CBR provides an overview on CBR Detection and Current Technology; and Indicators of CBR Contamination, Evacuation, Sheltering in Place, Air Filtration and Pressurization, and Exhausting and Purging. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-5 CBR Terrorist Incidents Since 1970 VISUAL VII-6 What is the CBR Threat? POTENTIAL IMPACT PROBABILITY/LIKELIHOOD BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-6 VISUAL VII-7 Why Would Terrorists Use CBR? . Ą Available and relatively easy to manufacture . Ą Large amounts not needed in an enclosed space . Ą Difficult to recognize . Ą Easily spread over large areas . Ą Strong psychological impact . Ą Overwhelms resources BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-7 CBR Terrorist Incidents Since 1970 CBR attacks have been used since ancient times and, in the past 20 years, over 50 attacks have occurred. CBR attacks require the right weather, population, and dispersion to be effective. Recent attacks have had limited effectiveness or have been conducted on a relatively small scale. Future attacks with Weapons of Mass Destruction could occur on a regional or global scale. What is the CBR Threat? A fundamental question, What is the CBR threat today? This slide shows the relationship between the probability or likelihood of threats, and their potential impacts. Why Would Terrorists Use CBR? . Ą Available and relatively easy to manufacture . Ą Large amounts not needed in an enclosed space . Ą Difficult to recognize . Ą Easily spread over large areas . Ą Strong psychological impact . Ą Overwhelms resources Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-8 CBR Sources . Ą Laboratory/commercial . Ą Industrial facilities . Ą Foreign military sources . Ą At least 25 countries possess chemical agents or weapons . Ą 10 countries are suspected to possess biological agents or weapons . Ą Medical/university research facilities . Ą Nuclear facilities . Ą Home production BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-8 VISUAL VII-9 Limitations of CBR Materials . Ą Effective dissemination is difficult. . Ą Delayed effects can detract from impact. . Ą Counterproductive to terrorists' support. . Ą Potentially hazardous to the terrorist. . Ą Development and use require skill. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY CBR Sources There are many potential sources of chemical and biological agents, including laboratory and commercial production, and home production in those cases involving low concentrations, and impure and inexpensive materials. Other sources include: . Ą Industrial facilities . Ą Foreign military sources . Ą Medical/university research facilities . Ą Nuclear facilities The next series of slides will examine in more detail the properties of chemical and biological agents, with implications for building design. Limitations of CBR Materials . Ą Effective dissemination is difficult. . Ą Delayed effects can detract from impact. . Ą Counterproductive to terrorists' support. . Ą Potentially hazardous to the terrorist. . Ą Development and use require skill. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-10 Chemical Agents: Characteristics and Behavior . Ą Generally liquid (when containerized) . Ą Normally disseminated as aerosol or gas . Ą Present both a respiratory and skin contact hazard . Ą May be detectable by the senses (especially smell) . Ą Influenced by weather conditions BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY VISUAL VII-11 Classes of Chemical Agents Chemical Agents: Characteristics and Behavior Classes of Chemical Agents Chemical agents are classified as either lethal or incapacitating and "riot control," according to their intended use. For the purposes of this presentation, the emphasis has been placed on lethal agents as a consequence of their greater capacity for terrorist mischief. . Ą Lethal: These have been subdivided into two categories: industrial materials used or considered as chemical warfare agents, and chemical warfare agents, which have little or no other purpose beyond their intended use as weapons of mass destruction on the battlefield. . Ą Incapacitating and Riot Control: Incapacitating and riot control agents are not considered as primary terrorist threats, due primarily to their relatively short duration of effects and minimal toxicity. Therefore, they are not discussed in detail in this unit. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-12 VISUAL VII-13 Note: At this point, reinforce the following point ...as we collectively examine and identify opportunities to improve building safety from CBR, it is important to understand the characteristics of CBR, and their potential consequences for the public, and first responders.... detailed information on the properties of these agents can be found in Appendix C of FEMA 426. Industrial Chemicals This chart lists four industrial chemicals that were previously used as chemical warfare agents. These chemicals are used in the sanitation industry, the plastics industry, and the pesticide industry. All of these agents are generally respiratory agents and can be protected against by effective respiratory protection (i.e., self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA)), although skin contact with concentrated material may cause chemical burns. They are all exceedingly volatile and dissipate rapidly outdoors. Comparative Toxicity This is a graphical comparison of the approximate lethalities of some chemical agents. They are based relative to Chlorine in terms of respiratory toxicity. If we use Chlorine as a baseline (1.0 on the graph): . Ą Phosgene (CG) is about 6 times more toxic . Ą Hydrogen Cyanide (AC) is about 7 times more toxic . Ą Parathion, an insecticide ingredient, is about 12 times more toxic . Ą Mustard (H) is about 13 times more toxic . Ą Sarin (GB) is about 200 times more toxic . Ą VX is about 600 times more toxic For skin toxicity, less than a pinhead of mustard agent is required to achieve a small blister. Less than a pinhead of VX can be lethal. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-14 Exam Questions #A15 and B15 VISUAL VII-15 Chemical Agents Key Points . Ą Chemical agents are supertoxic . Ą Relative toxicity: industrial chemicals < mustard < nerve . Ą Normal states are as a liquid or a vapor . Ą Inhalation hazard is of greatest concern BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-15 How Much Sarin Does it Take? We have all heard of Sarin, among the most lethal of chemical agents. It is both odorless and colorless in pure form. These numbers are the Lethal Doses 50 (LD50) amounts for 1 minute of exposure to Sarin liquid. This means that in a 60-second period, it would take approximately 26 gallons of Sarin to kill 50 percent of the people in a domed stadium, 5 cups of Sarin to kill 50 percent of the people in a movie theater, only about 1/4 cup of Sarin to kill 50 percent of the people in an auditorium, and the equivalent of a shot glass to kill 50 percent of the people in a 50-100 person conference room. Chemical Agents Key Points . Ą Chemical agents are supertoxic: These agents were deliberately developed to cause injury or death to individuals. . Ą Relative toxicity: industrial chemicals < mustard < nerve: In terms of relative toxicity, the same amount of an industrial chemical is less toxic than a blister agent, and both are less toxic than a nerve agent. . Ą Normal states are as a liquid or a vapor: These agents are either a liquid or a vapor in their normal state. . Ą Inhalation hazard is of greatest concern: Nerve and blister agents pose both a skin and inhalation hazard. The inhalation hazard is of greater concern. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-18 Bacteria Anthrax and plague are two examples of diseases caused by bacteria. This chart highlights the important characteristics of each, including: . Ą Incubation period . Ą Whether they are contagious . Ą Signs and symptoms . Ą Protection . Ą Treatment Again, a basic understanding of these characteristics will be valuable in developing an appropriate and effective protective action strategy for your facility. VISUAL VII-19 Viruses Two viruses are highlighted: Smallpox and Viral Hemorrhagic Fevers. Both are contagious, and protective actions include the use of standard and airborne and contact precautions. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-20 Toxins Note: There are numerous naturally-occurring toxins. For our purposes, we will group them into two categories. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-20 VISUAL VII-21 Exam Questions #A14 and B13 Biological weapons are considered the emerging mass weapon of destruction of choice for terrorists because many agents can be made with standard commercial laboratory or brewing equipment. Toxins Finally, there are numerous naturally-occurring toxins. For our purposes, we will group them into two categories: . Ą Neurotoxins: Neurotoxins attack the nervous system. They are fairly fast-acting and can act in a manner opposite to that of the nerve agents because they prevent nerve-to-muscle stimulation. . Ą Cytotoxins: Cytotoxins are cell poisons. They are slower acting and can have a variety of symptoms, including vomiting, diarrhea, rashes, blisters, jaundice, bleeding, or general tissue deterioration. There are numerous other modes of action of toxins, which are beyond our need to discuss here. Biological Agents Key Points . Ą Onset of symptoms: Most biological agents have an incubation period. Delayed effects will make identifying a biological attack more difficult. . Ą Contagious: Only a few biological agents are contagious: plague, smallpox, and viral hemorrhagic fevers (VHF), such as ebola . Ą Signs and symptoms: Signs and symptoms of many biological attacks initially manifest themselves as flu-like; therefore, it may be difficult to identify that an attack has occurred. . Ą Protection: Standard precautions will be adequate protection against most biological agents . Ą Treatment: Some biological agents can be treated with antibiotics, vaccines, and antitoxins; for agents for which there are Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-22 Nuclear/Radiological Materials Improvised Nuclear Devices Nuclear Plants Radiological Dispersal Device BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-22 VISUAL VII-23 Ionizing Radiation Alpha particles Beta particles Gamma rays Neutrons BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Exam Questions #A13 and B12 none of the aforementioned treatments, supportive care should be administered. The recent SARS and Avian Flu outbreaks demonstrate the relative ease by which naturally-occurring biological agents can quickly transmutate and spread across the globe. The flu strain that caused the Flu Pandemic of 1918 is still an active strain. Nuclear/Radiological Materials Of the three types of threats (chemical, biological, or nuclear/radiological), a nuclear weapon explosion is considered the least likely for terrorist use; however, the potential exists for it to happen and even more potential exists for the use of radiological materials. Possible scenarios: . Ą The detonation of an improvised nuclear device (IND) . Ą Terrorist attack on a nuclear plant . Ą Use of a radiological dispersal device (RDD), or "dirty" bomb - the simple act of spreading the materials Ionizing Radiation For our purposes, this radiation can be classified as: . Ą Alpha particles . Ą Beta particles . Ą Gamma rays . Ą Neutrons Again, for the purposes of this course, we are primarily concerned with the hazard, the detection of the hazard, and protective actions that we can take. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY Note: In its simplest definition, radiation can be defined as either electromagnetic or particulate emissions of energy from the disintegration of the nucleus of an atom. This energy, when impacting on or passing through material, including us, can cause some form of reaction. Radioactive material: Any material that is giving off some form of ionizing radiation. VISUAL VII-24 Common Radiation Exposures Chronic Acute BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Note: Mild radiation sickness (i.e., nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea) may onset after receiving a whole body dose of approximately 200,000 mrem in a short amount of time (generally less than 24 hours). The Lethal Dose (LD), known as the LD50/60, is a single, acute, whole body exposure of around 450,000 mrem. The LD50/60 is defined when 50 percent of all people present at an incident receive 450,000 mrem and die after 60 days after receiving no medical treatment. Ionizing radiation is what causes injury or death, and also a characteristic by which nuclear materials can be measured and identified. Common Radiation Exposures This chart reflects naturally-occurring radiation doses (and doses received during normal activities) to provide a point of reference and for comparison. The threshold for any real consequences begins around 200,000 mrem. The average annual radiation exposure has been calculated as: Naturally occurring 295 mrem Medical 52 mrem Consumer products 10 mrem Other 3 mrem Total 360 mrem Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-25 Health Hazards in an Incident . Ą Exposure to radiation source (external) . Ą Contamination (possible internal and/or external) BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Note: Internal exposure through wounds or broken skin is also possible. Responders should take extra precautions when sharp objects, such as broken glass or jagged metal, are at the scene. Exam Questions #A24 and B25 VISUAL VII-26 Protection from Radiation Exposure Time Distance Shielding BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Note: Do not shield neutron producing sources with lead or dense materials. Neutrons will produce gamma rays in reactions with the material. Use wax, water, or plastic. Health Hazards The two radiation concerns at an incident are exposure and contamination by radioactive material. External irradiation occurs when all or part of the body is exposed to penetrating radiation from an external source. Contamination means that radioactive materials in the form of gases, liquids, or solids are released into the environment and get on people externally, get in them, or both. Incidents involving either an explosion or fire will elevate the potential for internal or external contamination due to the spreading of the radioactive material in the form of small fragments (dust) or smoke. These materials can often be carried long distances downwind. Radiological materials are both colorless and odorless. Protection from Radiation Exposure The radiation exposure received will depend on the type and strength of radiation source. This exposure can be reduced by effective use of: . Ą Time: The radiation dose is reduced in proportion to reduction of exposure time. . Ą Distance: Distance is also critical for reducing radiation exposure dose. While alpha particles only travel a little over an inch in air, and beta particles will travel only a few yards in air, gamma rays can travel extensive distances. . Ą Shielding: Radiation can also be blocked or reduced by various materials. Alpha radiation is stopped by a sheet of paper, beta radiation is stopped by aluminum foil or clothing, gamma rays Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-27 CBR Detection Radiological Chemical Biological ? BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-27 Exam Questions #A19 and B20 Sources of useful technical information: Ą NBC Products and Services Handbook contains a catalogue of CBR detection equipment. . Ą Guide for the Selection of Chemical Agent and Toxic Industrial Material Detection Equipment for Emergency First Responders, published by the National Institute of Justice (NIJ), June 2001. . Ą An Introduction to Biological Agent Detection Equipment for Emergency First Responders, published by the NIJ (Guide 101-00: December 2001. are only reduced by dense materials such as lead or earth, and neutrons are slowed or stopped by hydrogenous materials, such as wax or water. CBR Detection The underlying theme of this chapter is that effective protection against potential releases of CBR is a function of: 1) effective and timely detection of the agent(s); and 2) a public that is knowledgeable of the most appropriate protective actions to take in the event of a CBR release. The discussion on CBR detection includes: . Ą CBR detection technology currently available. . Ą Indications of CBR contamination. . Ą Most strategies for protecting people from airborne hazards require a means of detection (determining that a hazard exists) . Ą Chemical detection technology has improved vastly since Operation Desert Storm (when many military detection systems experienced high false-alarm rates). Current chemical detectors work in about 10 seconds. . Ą Biological detection technology has not matured as fast; generally require trained specialists to administer; biological signatures can take 30 minutes to detect. A variety of radiological detectors have been developed for the nuclear industry and are commercially available. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-28 Chemical Incident Indicators (1) BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-28 VISUAL VII-29 Chemical Incident Indicators (2) BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-29 Exam Questions #A16 and B16 Chemical Incident Indicators (1) Most hazardous chemicals have warning properties that provide a practical means for detecting a hazard and initiating protective actions. Such warning properties make chemicals perceptible; for example, vapors or gases can be perceived by the human senses (i.e., smell, sight, taste, or irritation of the eyes, skin, or respiratory tract) before serious effects occur. In the absence of a warning property, people can be alerted to some airborne hazards by observing symptoms or effects in others. This provides a practical means for initiating protective actions, because the susceptibility to hazardous materials varies from person to person. Chemical Incident Indicators (2) This chart depicts the following chemical indicators: definite pattern of casualties; illness associated with a confined geographic area; unused liquid droplets; areas that look different in appearance; unexplained odors; low-flying clouds; and unusual metal debris. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-30 Biological Incident Indicators BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-30 VISUAL VII-31 Radiological Incident Indicators BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-31 VISUAL VII-32 CBR Protection Strategies Protective Actions: . Ą Evacuation . Ą Sheltering in Place . Ą Personal Protective Equipment . Ą Air Filtration and Pressurization . Ą Exhausting and Purging BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-28 Biological Incident Indicators In the case of a biological incident, the onset of symptoms takes days to weeks and, typically, there will be no characteristic indicators. Because of the delayed onset of symptoms in a biological incident, the area affected may be greater due to the migration of infected individuals. Radiological Incident Indicators In the case of a radiological incident, the onset of symptoms also takes days to weeks to occur and typically there will be no characteristic indicators. Radiological materials are not recognizable by the senses because they are colorless and odorless. CBR Protection Strategies Once the presence of an airborne hazard is detected, there are five possible protective actions for a building and its occupants. In increasing order of complexity and cost, these actions are: . Ą Evacuation . Ą Sheltering in Place . Ą Personal Protective Equipment . Ą Air Filtration and Pressurization . Ą Exhausting and Purging To ensure the protective actions are effective you must have: Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-33 Evacuation Most common protective action In most cases, existing plans for fire evacuation apply Ą Assembly should be upwind and at least 1,000 feet Two considerations in non-fire evacuation are: 1. 1. Determine if the source of the airborne hazard is internal or external. 2. 2. Determine if evacuation may lead to other risks. Also, evacuation and assembly should be to the upwind side of the building and at least 1,000 feet away, since any airborne hazard escaping the building will be carried downwind. . Ą A protective action plan specific to each building . Ą Training and familiarization for occupants. Protective actions are discussed in more detail in the following sections. Evacuation . Ą Evacuation is the most common protective action taken when an airborne hazard, such as smoke or an unusual odor, is perceived in a building. . Ą Orderly evacuation is the simplest and most reliable action for an internal airborne hazard, but may not be the best action in all situations, especially in the case of an external CBR release, particularly one that is widespread. . Ą If some agent has infiltrated the building and evacuation is deemed not to be safe, the use of protective hoods may be appropriate. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-34 Sheltering in Place (1) A building can provide substantial protection against agents released outside if the flow of fresh air is halted or significantly reduced The amount of protection varies with: . Ą How tight the building is . Ą Duration of exposure . Ą Purging or period of occupancy . Ą Natural filtering BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-30 Exam Questions #A12 and B14 In most cases, air conditioners and combustion heaters cannot be operated while sheltering in place because operating them increases the indoor-outdoor exchange of air. Sheltering in place is, therefore, suitable only for exposures of short duration, roughly 2 hours or less, depending on conditions. Because the building slowly releases contaminants that have entered, at some point during cloud passage the concentration inside exceeds the concentration outside. Maximum protection is attained by increasing the air exchange rate after cloud passage or by exiting the building into clean air. The tighter the building, the greater the effect of this natural filtering. Sheltering in Place (1) Interrupting the flow of fresh air is the principal applied in the protective action known as sheltering in place. Advantage: It can be implemented rapidly. Disadvantage: Protection is variable and diminishes with the duration of the hazard. The level of protection that can be attained by sheltering in place is substantial, but it is less than can be provided by high-efficiency filtration of the fresh air introduced into the building. The amount of protection varies with: . Ą The building's air exchange rate. The tighter the building (i.e., the lower the air exchange rate), the greater the protection it provides. . Ą The duration of exposure. Protection varies with time, diminishing as the time of exposure increases. . Ą Purging or period of occupancy. How long occupants remain in the building after the hazardous cloud has passed also affects the level of protection. . Ą Natural filtering. Some filtering occurs when the agent is deposited in the building shell or upon interior surfaces as air passes into and out of the building. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-35 Sheltering in Place (2) . Ą Sheltering Plan should include: . Ą Identifying all HVAC equipment to be deactivated . Ą Identify cracks, seams, and joints to be temporarily sealed . Ą Prepositioning supplies . Ą Identify safe rooms . Ą Identify procedures for purging . Ą Identify procedures for voluntary occupant participation BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-31 Exam Questions #A20 and B19 Note: Although sheltering is for protection against an external release, it is possible, but more complex, to shelter in place in one or more floors of a multi-story building after an internal release has occurred. In these circumstances, it is critical to isolate stairwells, and not use elevators. VISUAL VII-36 Personal Protective Equipment Note: This slide depicts individuals wearing universal-fit escape hoods (upper left-hand corner picture and middle picture on the slide) Sheltering in Place (2) If the office environment is complex, planning and exercises is important. The sheltering plan should include: . Ą Identifying all air handling units, fans, and the switches needed to deactivate them . Ą Identifying cracks, seams, and joints, in the building shell to be temporarily sealed . Ą Prepositioning supplies . Ą Identifying safe rooms . Ą Identifying procedures for voluntary occupant participation . Ą Identifying procedures for purging after an internal release . Ą Sealing doors with duct tape . Ą Turning on TV or radio During an event, the decision to shelter in place is voluntary, but people should enter the designated shelter area within 3-5 minutes. Personal Protective Equipment . Ą A wide range of individual protection equipment is available, including respirators, protective hoods, protective suits, CBR detectors, decontamination equipment, etc. . Ą If masks have been issued, ensure that training is conducted on how to put on and wear the masks. . Ą No selection of personal protective equipment is effective against every possible threat. Selection must be tied to specific threat/hazard characteristics. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY that have been developed for short-duration "escape-only" wear to protect against chemical agents, aerosols (including biological agents), and some toxic industrial chemicals. The hoods are compact enough to be stored in desks (see picture in upper left-hand corner of the slide) or to be carried on the belt. Exam Questions #A21 and B23 VISUAL VII-37 Filtration and Pressurization . Ą Requires modifications to HVAC and electrical systems - significant initial and life-cycle costs . ĄIntroduces filtered air at a rate sufficient to produce an overpressure and create an outward flow through leaks and cracks Note: Applying external filtration to a building requires modification to the building's heating, ventilation, air conditioning (HVAC) system and electrical system. These changes are necessary to ensure that, when the protective system is in operation, all outside air enters the building through filters. The air exchange that normally occurs due to wind pressure, chimney effect, and operation of fans must be reduced to zero. Ą Universal hoods designed for short duration escape wear only protect against chemical agents by using both HEPA and carbon filters. Filtration and Pressurization . Ą Two basic methods of applying air filtration to a building are external filtration and internal filtration. External filtration involves filtering and/or cleaning of the air drawn from the outside, while internal filtration involves filtering and/or cleaning of the air drawn from inside the building. Both methods require HVAC modifications that can be costly. . Ą Among the various protective measures for buildings, high efficiency air filtration/cleaning provides the highest level of protection against an outdoor release of hazardous materials. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-38 Air Filtration and Cleaning Two Types of Collection Systems: Particulate air filtration . Ą Principles of collection . Ą Types of particulate filters . Ą Filter testing and efficiency ratings Gas-phase air filtration . Ą Principles of collection . Ą Types of gas-phase filters BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-34 Exam Questions #A23 and B21 Air Filtration and Cleaning Air filtration is the removal of particulate contaminants from the air. Air cleaning is the removal of gases or vapors from the air. The collection mechanisms for these two types of systems are very different. Particulate air filtration consists of fibrous materials, which capture aerosols. Their efficiency will depend on the size of the aerosol, the type of filter, the velocity of the air, and the type of microbe. The basic principle of particulate air filtration is not to restrict the passage of particles by the gap between fibers, but by altering the airflow streamlines. The airflow will slip around the fiber, but higher density aerosols and particulates will not change direction as rapidly. Particulate filters are not intended to remove gases and vapors. Gas-phase air filtration sorbent filters use one of two mechanisms for capturing and controlling gas-phase air contaminants, physical absorption. Both mechanisms remove specific types of gas-phase contaminants in indoor air. Unlike particulate filters, sorbents cover a wide range of highly porous materials, ranging from simple clays and carbons to complex engineered polymers. Activated carbon is the most common sorbent, but does not capture all chemicals. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-39 Air Contaminant Sizes BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VII-35 Exam Questions #A22 and B22 VISUAL VII-40 Various Filter Types Pleated Panel Filters Air Contaminant Sizes This chart illustrates the particle size for a number of the chemical, biological, and radiological agents of concern. Viruses are the smallest and most difficult to protect against. In FEMA 426, Table 5-1 lists the new ASHRAE 52.2 Standards for particulate filter ratings to remove a given particle size. In most cases, new generation MERV 11 to MERV 13 filters can be used in commercial buildings and effectively remove most particulates of CBR concern. Various Filter Types A wide variety of filters are available to meet many specialized needs: . Ą HEPA (high efficiency particulate air) Filters - high performance filters that are typically rated as 99.97 percent effective in removing dust and particulate matter greater than 0.3 micron in size. . Ą Carbon Filters - sorbent filters (gas-phase) that remove gas and vapors using the thousands of bonding sites on the huge surface area of activated carbon. . Ą Pleated Panel Filters - particulate air filters consisting of fibrous materials that capture aerosols. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-41 VISUAL VII-42 VISUAL VII-43 ASHRAE Standards (1) The new ASHRAE Standard 52.2 is a more descriptive test than ASHRAE Standard 52.1. Standard 52.2 quantifies filtration efficiency in different particle size ranges and is more applicable in determining a filter's effectiveness to capture a specific agent. Standard 52.2 reports the particle size efficiency results as a Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value (MERV) rating between 1 and 20. A higher MERV rating indicates a more efficient filter. ASHRAE Standards (2) The standard provides a table (depicted on the slide) that shows minimum Particle Size Efficiency (PSE) for three size ranges for each of the MERV numbers 1 through 16. Thus, if the size of a contaminant is known, an appropriate filter with the desired PSE for that particular particle size can be identified. Typical Performance of a HEPA Filter HEPA filters are typically rated as 99.97 percent effective in removing dust and particulate matter greater than 0.3 micron in size. A typical HEPA performance curve is depicted on this slide. The dip between 0.1 and 0.3 microns represents the most penetrating particle size. Many bacteria and viruses fall into this size range. Fortunately, microbes in this range are also vulnerable to ultraviolet radiation. For this reason, many Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-44 Note: Mention that a ventilation system and smoke purge fans can be used to purge the building after an external release after the hazard outdoors has dissipated, and it has been confirmed that the agent is no longer present near the building. Exam Questions #A25 and B24 facilities couple particulate air filters with ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI). UVGI will be discussed on slide VII-49. Exhausting and Purging The fifth protective measure for CBR covered in FEMA 426 is Exhausting and Purging. Turning on a building's ventilation fans and smoke-purge fans is a protective action for purging airborne hazards from the building and reducing the hazard to which building occupants are exposed, but it is mainly useful when the source of the hazard is indoors. . Ą Purging must be carefully applied with regard to the location of the source and the time of the release. It must be clear that the source of the hazard is inside the building and, if not, purging should not be attempted. . Ą If the hazardous material has been identified before release or immediately upon release, purging should not be employed, because it may spread the hazardous material throughout the building or zone. In this case, all air handling units should be turned off to isolate the hazard while evacuating or temporarily sheltering in place. The indoor-outdoor air exchange rate can be increased by opening all windows and energizing all fans. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-45 VISUAL VII-46 VISUAL VII-47 Issues to Consider . Ą What is the threat? . Ą How clean does the air need to be? . Ą What is the current system capacity? . Ą Is there filter bypass? . Ą Will improved indoor air quality offset upgrade costs? . Ą Is system maintenance addressed? Economic Issues to Consider In developing, implementing, and sustaining a program to reduce vulnerability to terrorist threats, there are economic issues to consider, including three categories of costs: . Ą Initial costs . Ą Operating costs . Ą Replacement costs These need to be factored into protection strategies. Access to Outdoor Intakes . Ą Several physical security measures can be applied to reduce the potential for hazardous materials entering a building through the HVAC system. . Ą One of the most important steps in protecting a building's indoor environment is the security of the outdoor air intakes. Outdoor air enters the building through these intakes and is distributed throughout the building by the HVAC system. . Ą If relocation of outdoor air intakes is not Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY Note: The goal of this protective measure is to minimize public accessibility. In general, this means the higher the extensions, the better- as long as other design constraints (excessive pressure loss, dynamic and static loads on structure) are appropriately considered. VISUAL VII-48 VISUAL VII-49 Note: UVGI has long been used in laboratories and health care facilities. Ultraviolet radiation in the range of 2,250-3,020 Angstroms is lethal to microorganisms. All viruses and almost all bacteria (excluding spores) are vulnerable to moderate levels of UVGI exposure. Spores, which are larger and more resistant to UVGI feasible, intake extensions can be constructed without creating adverse effects on HVAC performance. Extension Design Recommendations An extension height of 12 feet will place the intake out of reach of individuals without some assistance. Also, the entrance to the intake should be covered with a sloped metal mesh to reduce the threat of objects being tossed into the intake. A minimum slope of 45ˇ is generally adequate. Extension height should be increased where existing platforms or building features (i.e., loading docks, retaining walls) might provide access to the outdoor air intakes. Ultraviolet Germicidal Irradiation (UVGI) A design utilizing a combination of filtration and UVGI can be very effective against biological agents. Smaller microbes, which are difficult to filter out, tend to be more susceptible to UVGI, while larger microbes, such as spores, which are more resistant to UVGI, tend to be easier to filter out. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY than most bacteria, can be effectively removed through high efficiency air filtration. Consequently, most UGVI systems are installed in conjunction with high efficiency filtration systems. VISUAL VII-50 Note: Building envelopes in residential and commercial buildings are, in general, quite leaky, and significant quantities of air can infiltrate the building envelope with minimal filtration. Field studies have shown that, unless specific measures are taken to reduce infiltration, as much air may enter a building through infiltration as through the mechanical ventilation system. Infiltration and Bypass Infiltration. Building managers should not expect filtration alone to protect a building from outdoor releases, particularly for systems in which no make-up air or inadequate overpressure is present. Filtration, in combination with other steps, such as building pressurization and tightening the building envelope, should be considered to increase the likelihood that the air entering the building actually passes through the filtration and air-cleaning systems. Bypass. Filter bypass is a common problem found in many HVAC filtration systems. It occurs when air, rather than moving through the filter, goes around it, decreasing collection efficiency and defeating the intended purpose of the filtration system. Filter bypass is often caused by poorly fitting filters, poor sealing of filters in their framing systems, missing filter panels, or leaks and openings in the air handling unit downstream of the filter bank and upstream of the blower. Simply improving filter efficiency without addressing filter bypass provides little, if any, improvement to system efficiency. As a mechanical system loads with particulates over time, its collection efficiency increases, but so does the pressure drop. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-51 Things Not to Do More than anything else, building owners and managers should ensure that any actions they take do not have a detrimental effect on the building systems (HVAC, fire protection, life safety, etc.) or the building occupants under normal building operation. Some efforts to protect the building from a CBR attack could have adverse effects on the building's indoor environmental quality. Building owners and managers should understand how the building systems operate and assess the impact of security measures on those systems. VISUAL VII-52 Summary . Ą CBR threats are real and growing. . Ą Industrial chemicals are readily available. . Ą Military chemicals require specialty expertise. . Ą Most buildings provide a reasonable level of protection. . Ą Inside versus outside building release determines evacuation decision. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VII-53 Refer participants to FEMA 426 and the Unit VII Case Study activity in the Student Manual. Members of the instructor staff should be available to answer questions and assist groups as needed. At the end of 10 minutes, reconvene the class and facilitate group reporting. 1. 1. Distribute the exam (Version A or B) and answer sheet. Ask the students to record their name and the date. Remind them that the test is an open book exam. 2. 2. Allow 30 minutes for test completion, then collect the tests and answer sheets. 3. 3. Score the tests. 4. 4. Return the students' tests and answer sheets, and review the correct answers by calling on the students to give the answers. Encourage them to ask questions, and explain (as needed) why each answer is correct. When finished, collect the tests and answer sheets. Student Activity This activity provides a check on learning about the nature of chemical, biological, and radiological agents. Activity Requirements Working in small groups, refer to the HIC Case Study and FEMA 426 to answer the worksheet questions. Take 10 minutes to complete this activity. Solutions will be reviewed in plenary group. Transition This completes the information Units I through VII. A written exam will cover these units. Unit VIII will cover Building Design Guidance. Units VIII through XI will not have a written exam. WRITTEN EXAM Two versions of the written exam (with answer sheet) are provided in Appendix B of the Student Manual: . Ą Version A . Ą Version B Use the provided Scoring Sheet. Correct answers and their sources are listed on the Answer Keys, which follow. Unit VII: Chemical, Biological, and Radiological (CBR) Measures UNIT VII CASE STUDY ACTIVITY: CHEMICAL, BIOLOGICAL, AND RADIOLOGICAL (CBR) CONSIDERATIONS The requirements in this Unit's activity are intended to provide a check on learning about the nature of chemical, biological, and radiological agents. Requirement 1. Review the HIC Case Study and name the prevalent CBR threat(s) to the HIC. Chemical - fire and toxic fumes from an explosion at the petroleum tank farm, HazMat spills on the interstate or rail line Biological - Anthrax delivered by mail, smallpox by spray mechanism Radiological - "dirty" Bomb Refer to Table 5-1 on page 5-12 of FEMA 426 and answer the following questions: 1. 2. What size filtration unit (MERV) is required to filter out 75 percent of Legionella and dust particulates (1 to 3 microns) inside the HIC? 11 2. 3. What range of MERV is required to remove 85 percent of smoke particles greater than 0.3 micron in size? 15 3. 4. What mitigation measure can be used in the HVAC systems to destroy bacteria and viruses? UVGI lamps Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII COURSE TITLE Building Design for Homeland Security TIME 150 minutes UNIT TITLE Site and Layout Design Guidance OBJECTIVES 1. 1. Explain the concerns of land use as applied to threats and hazards due to terrorism and technological accidents 2. 2. Identify site planning concerns that can create, reduce, or eliminate vulnerabilities and understand the concept of "Layers of Defense" 3. 3. Compare the pros and cons of barrier mitigation measures that increase stand-off or create controlled access zones 4. 4. Identify the positive and negative aspects of mitigation approaches for entry control and vehicle access, signage, parking, loading docks, lighting, and site utilities 5. 5. Explain the basic concepts of Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) and its applicability to building security against terrorism 6. 6. Apply these concepts to an existing site or building and identify mitigation measures needed to reduce vulnerabilities SCOPE The following topics will be covered in this unit: 1. 1. Land use considerations both outside and inside the property line 2. 2. Site planning issues to include site design, layout and form, vehicular and pedestrian circulation, and landscape and urban design 3. 3. Creating stand-off distance using perimeter controls, non-exclusive zones, and exclusive zones along with the design concepts and technology to consider 4. 4. Design considerations and mitigation measures for building security REFERENCES 1. FEMA 426, Reference Manual to Mitigate Potential Terrorist Attacks Against Buildings, Chapter 2 1. 2. Student Manual, Unit VIII 2. 3. Case Study 3. 4. Unit VIII visuals Unit VIII REQUIREMENTS 1. FEMA 426, Reference Manual to Mitigate Potential Terrorist Attacks Against Buildings (one per student) 1. 2. Instructor Guide 2. 3. Student Manual (one per student) 3. 4. Overhead projector or computer display unit 4. 5. Unit VIII visuals 5. 6. Chart paper, easel, and markers UNIT VIII OUTLINE Time Page VIII. Site and Layout Design Guidance 150 minutes IG VIII-1 1. 1. Introduction and Unit Overview 5 minutes IG VIII-3 2. 2. Layout Design and Land Use Considerations 15 minutes IG VIII-4 3. 3. Site Planning Issues 15 minutes IG VIII-5 4. 4. Entry Control and Vehicle Access 15 minutes IG VIII-9 5. 5. Design Considerations and Mitigation Measures 20 minutes IG VIII-11 6. 6. Walk-through of Building Vulnerability Assessment 20 minutes IG VIII-21 Checklist 7. 7. Activity: Site and Layout Design Guidance 60 minutes IG VIII-23 PREPARING TO TEACH THIS UNIT . Ą Tailoring Content to the Local Area: Review the Instructor Notes to identify topics that should focus on the local area. Plan how you will use the generic content, and prepare for a locally oriented discussion. . Ą Optional Activity: There are no optional activities in this unit. . Ą Activity: There is no student activity associated with this unit. However, information in this unit will be used during the student activities associated with Chapters 2 and 3. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-1 BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII Site and Layout DesignGuidance VISUAL VIII-2 and 3 Introduction and Unit Overview This is Unit VIII Site and Layout Design Guidance. This lecture will examine site level considerations and concepts for integrating land use planning, landscape, architecture, site planning, and other strategies to mitigate the design basis threats. The students will gain an understanding of the myriad options available to enhance site design taking into account many environmental challenges. Unit Objectives At the end of this unit, you should be able to: 1. 1. Explain the concerns of land use as applied to threats and hazards due to terrorism and technological accidents. 2. 2. Identify site planning concerns that can create, reduce, or eliminate vulnerabilities and understand the concept of "Layers of Defense." 3. 3. Compare the pros and cons of barrier mitigation measures that increase stand-off or create controlled access zones. 4. 4. Identify the positive and negative aspects of mitigation approaches for entry control and vehicle access, signage, parking, loading docks, lighting, and site utilities. 5. 5. Explain the basic concepts of Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) and its applicability to building security against terrorism. 6. 6. Apply these concepts to an existing site or building and identify mitigation measures needed to reduce vulnerabilities. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-4 Layout and Site Design Layout Design Siting Entry Control and Vehicle Access Signage Parking Loading Docks Physical Security Lighting Site Utilities BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-4 VISUAL VIII-5 Layers of Defense Note: Layers of Defense will be used through out the course and in Unit X Electronic Security Systems and illustrate the elements: . Ą Deter . Ą Detect . Ą Deny . Ą Devalue Instructors may want to relate to a castle. Site and Layout Design . Ą Layout Design . Ą Siting . Ą Entry Control/Vehicle Access . Ą Signage . Ą Parking . Ą Loading Docks . Ą Physical Security Lighting . Ą Site Utilities Layers of Defense . Ą First layer starts at the site perimeter and outward . Ą Second layers between the site perimeter and building . Ą Third layer is building and interior It is important to remember that the nature of any threat is always changing. Although indications of potential threats may be scarce during the design stage, consideration should be given to accommodating enhanced protection measures in response to future threats that may emerge. Asset protection must be balanced with other design objectives, such as the efficient use of land and resources, and must also take into account existing physical, programmatic, and fiscal constraints. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-6 Identify Adjacent Hazards First Layer of Defense Note the large fuel storage and distribution facility in the vicinity of the office building being assessed. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-6 VISUAL VIII-7 Layout Design First Layer of Defense BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-7 Identify Adjacent Hazards The designer should study the surrounding areas to identify particular threats/hazards. For this purpose, GIS is an excellent resource. Using GIS applications enable designers and building owners to analyze various demographic, hazardous areas, transportation networks, access control points, etc. These applications may depict a true picture of the surrounding threats, allowing decision-makers to take proactive measurements to mitigate potential vulnerabilities. Layout Design Depending on the site characteristics, the occupancy requirements, and other factors, buildings may be clustered tightly in one area, or dispersed across the site. Both patterns have compelling strengths and weaknesses. Concentrating people, property, and operations in one place creates a target-rich environment, and the mere proximity of any one building to any other may increase the risk of collateral impacts. Additionally, the potential exists for the establishment of more single-point vulnerabilities in a clustered design than would exist in a more dispersed pattern. However, grouping high risk activities, concentrations of personnel, and critical functions into a cluster can help maximize stand-off from the perimeter and create a "defensible space." Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-8 Layout Design First Layer of Defense Orientation has a significant impact on making the building visible to aggressors. Enhance surveillance opportunities while minimizing views into the building. . BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-8 VISUAL VIII-9 Siting First Layer of Defense Figure 2-7: Clear Zone with Unobstructed Views, page 2-21 BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-9 A clear zone facilitates monitoring of the immediate vicinity and visual detection of attacks. Walkways and other circulation features within a clear zone should located so that buildings do not block view of pedestrians Layout Design Orientation is the building's spatial relationship to the site, its orientation relative to the sun, and its vertical or horizontal aspect relative to the ground. The physical positioning of a building relative to its surroundings may seem subtle, but can be a greater determinant of security. Good site design, orientation and building placement should allow building occupants to look out of the facility while minimizing views into the building. The proximity of a vulnerable faŤade to a parking area, street, adjacent site, or other area that is accessible to vehicles and/or difficult to observe can greatly contribute to its vulnerability. Siting For high risk buildings, it may be necessary to provide additional protection by creating a clear zone immediately adjacent to the structure that is free of all visual obstructions or landscaping. The clear zone facilitates monitoring of the immediate vicinity and visual detection of attacks. Walkways and other circulation features within a clear zone should be located so that buildings do not block views of pedestrians and vehicles. If clear zones are implemented, it may be necessary to implement other anti-surveillance measures. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY and vehicles. VISUAL VIII-10 Siting First Layer of Defense Stand-off Distance BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-10 VISUAL VIII-11 Siting First Layer of Defense BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-11 Stand-off Distance The distance between an asset and a threat is referred to as the stand-off distance, as shown in Visual VIII-10. There is no ideal stand-off distance; it is determined by the type of threat, the type of construction, and desired level of protection. The primary design strategy is to keep terrorists away from inhabited buildings. Although sufficient stand-off distance is not always possible in conventional construction, maximizing the distance may be the most cost-effective solution. Maximizing stand-off distance also ensures that there is opportunity in the future to upgrade buildings to meet increased threats or to accommodate higher levels of protection. Siting Controlled access zones may be exclusive or non-exclusive. An exclusive zone is the area surrounding a building within the exclusive control of the building. Anyone entering an exclusive zone must have a purpose related to the building. A non-exclusive zone is either a public right-of-way or an area related to several buildings. Someone entering a non-exclusive zone could be headed for any building within that area. Public access areas outside a downtown building would typically be considered non-exclusive. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-12 Siting First Layer of Defense BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-12 VISUAL VIII-13 Entry Control/Vehicular Access Prevent unauthorized access . Ą Avoid traffic queuing . Ą Rejection routes . Ą Search area out of traffic flow Traffic calming . Ą Avoid high speed approaches . Ą Commercial vehicle gate BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-13 Siting A number of elements may be used to create a physical barrier, some natural and some manmade. Natural barrier elements include rivers, lakes, waterways, steep terrain, mountains, barren areas, plants, and other terrain features that are difficult to traverse. Manmade elements include fencing, walls, buildings, bollards, planters, concrete barriers, and fountains. Selection of elements must consider the level of security desired and the type of threat most likely to occur. Entry Control/Vehicular Access Entry control and vehicular access should: . Ą Prevent unauthorized access . Ą Provide for traffic calming . Ą Have commercial vehicle gates if possible . Ą Have equal capacity for exit Existing streets can be retrofitted with barriers, bollards, swing gates, or other measures to force vehicles to travel in a serpentine path. Again, high curbs and other measures should be installed to keep vehicles from departing the roadway in an effort to avoid these countermeasures. Less radical than these techniques are traffic calming strategies, which seek to use design measures to cue drivers as to the acceptable speed for an area. These include raised crosswalks, speed humps and speed tables, pavement treatments, build outs, and traffic circles. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-14 Entry Control/Vehicular Access and Roadway Design First Layer of Defense BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-14 Entry Control/Vehicular Access and Roadway Design The design of entry control and access points for vehicular and pedestrian circulation patterns can impact security. An entry-control point or guard building serves well as the designated point of entry for site access. It provides a point for implementation of desired/required levels of screening and access control. The objective of the entry control point is to prevent unauthorized access while maximizing the rate of authorized access by foot or vehicle. Location selection for vehicular access and entry control for a building starts with an evaluation of the anticipated demand for access to the controlled site. An analysis of traffic origin and destination, and an analysis of the capability of the surrounding connecting road network, including its capacity to handle additional traffic, should then be performed. Expansion capacity should also be considered. The analysis should be coordinated with the state and local departments of transportation. The existing terrain can have a significant impact on the suitability of a potential entry control point site. Flat terrain with no thick vegetation is generally preferred. A gentle rise in elevation up to the entry control guard building allows for a clear view of arriving vehicles. Consider how existing natural features such as bodies of water or dense tree stands may enhance perimeter security and vehicle containment. Entry control spatial requirements vary, depending on the type, the traffic demand, and the necessary security measures. Roadway network design that uses straight-line approaches to buildings may give approaching Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-15 VISUAL VIII-16 Building Siting and View Relationships First Layer of Defense Blocking Sight Lines BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-16 vehicles the opportunity gather the necessary speed to ram protective barriers and crash into buildings. Possible solution: design approaches to be parallel to the faŤade, with berms, high curbs, trees, and other measures used to prevent vehicles from departing the roadway. Site Access and Entry Control Robust vehicle inspection points can be used to inspect vehicles. The covered top provides protection from inclement weather. Building Siting and View Relationships Landscape and urban design inherently define the "line of sight" in a space. Operational security is not a traditional element of master planning, but managing the threat of hostile surveillance is a significant consideration in protecting people, property, and operations. With careful selection, placement, and maintenance, landscape elements can provide visual screening that protects sensitive operations, gathering areas, and other activities from surveillance without creating concealment for covert activity. These techniques seek to deny aggressors a "line of sight" to a potential target, either from on or off site. This increases the protection of sensitive information and operations by using stand-off weapons. In addition to the use of various screening options, anti-surveillance measures (e.g., building orientation, landscaping, screening, and landforms) can Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-17 Building Siting and View Relationships First Layer of Defense Blocking Sight Lines and Establishing Clear Zones BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-17 VISUAL VIII-18 Urban Design Second Layer of Defense Given that the energy transferred when one object strikes another is a function of its mass and its velocity, a bollard that can stop a 15,000-pound truck moving at 35 miles per hour may not be able to stop the same truck moving at 55 miles per hour. In developing a system of street alignments with protection in mind, the designer cannot determine the size or weight of a vehicle that will travel along the road, because that is a management decision. However, the designer can propose a roadway system to minimize vehicle velocity, thus using the roadway itself as a protective measure. also be used to block sight lines. Building Siting and View Relationships Landforms can have a direct bearing on the security of a facility. They can be either beneficial (e.g., an elevated site that may enhance the surveillance of the surrounding area), or detrimental to anti-surveillance. Generally speaking: Ą For security purposes, buildings should not be sited immediately adjacent to higher surrounding terrain. Urban Design (1) Streets in urban areas can minimize travel time and at the same time maximize safety. Although a straight line may be the most efficient course, designers should use caution when orienting streets relative to buildings. Most urban building lines are located within 50 feet of the street curb. The street can become the second layer of defense and provide standoff distance through the use of terrain, curvature, and streetscape furniture to prevent vehicles from approaching the building. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-19 VISUAL VIII-20 Urban Design Second Layer of Defense BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-20 Urban Design (2) Numerous urban design elements present opportunities to provide security. The scale of the streetscape should be appropriate to its primary users, and it can be manipulated to increase the comfort level of desired users while creating a less inviting atmosphere for users with malicious intent. However, even at the pedestrian scale, certain operational requirements must be accommodated. For example, although efficient pedestrian and vehicle circulation systems are important for day-to-day living, they are also critical for emergency response, evacuation, and egress. Furthermore, despite an emphasis on downsizing the scale of the streetscape, it is critical to maintain the maximum stand-off distance possible between vehicles and structures. Urban Design (3) . Ą Street furniture can be used to deter potential damage to buildings. . Ą It is critical to maintain the maximum stand-off distance possible between vehicles and structures. . Ą At the site perimeter, walls and fences used for space definition may be hardened to resist the impact of a weapon-laden truck; however, planters, bollards, or decorative boulders could accomplish the same objective in a much more aesthetically pleasing manner. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-21 VISUAL VIII-22 Explain the advantages of blocking the site of critical assets. Discuss the advantages of the placement of bollards and raised walls. Urban Design (4) Existing streets can be retrofitted with barriers, bollards, swing gates, or other measures to force vehicles to travel in a serpentine path. Again, high curbs and other measures should be installed to keep vehicles from departing the roadway in an effort to avoid these countermeasures. Bollard Applications Concrete bollards are excellent barriers that can prevent high speed approaches. These are examples of bollard placement. When placing bollards, make sure you adhere to ADA compliance. Bollards can be appealing streetscapes, depending on the current environment where they are installed. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-23 Discuss the vehicle speed and the damage caused by velocity. Physical Protective Barriers Passive physical protective barriers can be used in parking lots, garages, next to buildings, and to create separate security zones. There are three primary types of parking facilities, all of which present security trade-offs. Surface lots can be designed to keep vehicles away from buildings, but they consume large amounts of land and, if constructed of impervious materials, can contribute greatly to stormwater runoff volume. They can also be hazardous for pedestrians if dedicated pedestrian pathways are not provided. In contrast, non-street parking is often convenient for users and a source of revenue for local governments, but this type of parking may provide little or no setback. Finally, garage structures provide revenue and can be convenient for users, but they may require structural measures to ensure blast resistance as well as crime prevention measures to prevent street crime. Although the cost of land suggests that the construction of a garage below a building (either underground or aboveground) may be the most economically viable approach for many developments, they can be highly vulnerable to vehicle-borne weapons, endangering the building above If garages must be used, human security procedures (e.g., vehicle searches) and electronic systems (e.g., closed circuit television) may be necessary. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-24 VISUAL VIII-25 VISUAL VIII-26 Physical Protective Barriers An active vehicle barrier is designed using the expected vehicle mass and velocity. Passive Vehicle Barrier Application A passive vehicle barrier can absorb a significant force and either stop or deflect the vehicle. Active Vehicle Barrier An active barrier can be activated in seconds and is capable of stopping large vehicles. Pop-up barriers can create serious damage to vehicles. These are some examples. Explain the vehicle impact damage in relation to high speed approaches. Greater force equals greater damage. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-27 Active Vehicle Barrier Application World Bank Washington, DC BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-27 VISUAL VIII-28 VISUAL VIII-29 Active Vehicle Barrier Application An example of active barriers is this one at the World Bank. The barriers stay in the down position during normal conditions, but are manned and deployed to the up position at higher threat levels. This is a typical pop-up barrier that is electronically controlled. Temporary Active Vehicle Barriers There are several temporary active vehicle barriers that can be rapidly deployed and moved into position to control site and parking access, control traffic flow, and provide standoff distance for buildings. Signage Unless required, signs should not identify sensitive areas. A comprehensive signage plan should be tailored to the mission of the facility accompanying the FEMA 426 guidelines. Minimize signs identifying critical utility complexes such as power plants and water treatment plants. Warning signs must use both languages in areas where two or more languages are commonly spoken. The wording on the signs Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-30 Parking Maintain stand-off distance Restrict parking and access between buildings Consider one-way circulation in parking lots Locate parking within view of occupied buildings Restrict parking underneath buildings Well-lit, with security presence, emergency communications, and/or CCTV Apply progressive collapse hardening to columns when parking garage is in the building BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-30 VISUAL VIII-31 Note the physical barriers that are in place to prevent vehicles entering underground parking areas. should denote warning of a restricted area. Signs should be posted at intervals of no more than 100 feet and should not be mounted on fences equipped with intrusion-detection equipment. Warning signs should be posted at all entrances to limited, controlled, and exclusion areas. Locate variable message signs, which give information on site/organization special events and visitors, far inside site perimeters. Parking (1) . Ą Maintain stand-off distance . Ą Restrict parking and access . Ą Consider one-way circulation . Ą Locate within view of occupied buildings . Ą Restrict parking underneath buildings . Ą Keep parking areas well lit . Ą Apply progressive collapse hardening to high risk structures Parking (2) . Ą Avoid having driveways or parking within or under buildings. Significant structural damage to the walls and ceiling of the loading dock may be acceptable; however, the areas adjacent to the loading dock should not experience severe structural damage or collapse. . Ą Provide signage to clearly mark separate entrances for deliveries. . Ą Visitor screening areas, receiving and loading areas, and mailrooms constitute the innermost line of defense, because they may be the first places where people and Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-32 Loading Docks/Service Access Ensure separation from critical systems and utility service entrances. Avoid driving trucks into or under building. Provide clear signage. Large truck carrying large bomb could go relatively unnoticed unless access control performed a significant distance from loading dock. BUILDING DESIGN FOR HOMELAND SECURITY Unit VIII-32 VISUAL VIII-33 Discuss the other vulnerability pictured here. The trash dumpster should be relocated away from the building. Explosive devices can be tossed in the dumpster creating a blast effect. materials are closely inspected before being introduced into the facility. Loading Docks and Service Access Loading docks and service access areas are commonly required for a building and are typically desired to be kept as invisible as possible. For this reason, special attention should be devoted to avoid undesirable intruders. Design criteria for loading docks and service access include the following: Separate (by at least 50 feet) loading docks and shipping and receiving areas in any direction from utility rooms, utility mains, and service entrances, including electrical, telephone/data, fire detection/alarm systems, fire suppression water mains, cooling and heating mains, etc. Loading docks are sometimes located near critical assets just inside the building and a blast effect would be detrimental to the entire building and could result in a progressive collapse. Loading Dock Example Locate loading docks so that vehicles will not be allowed under the building. If this is not possible, the service should be hardened for blast. Loading dock design should limit damage to adjacent areas and vent explosive forces to the exterior of the building. If loading zones or drive-through areas are necessary, monitor them and restrict height to keep out large vehicles. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-34 VISUAL VIII-35 VISUAL VIII-36 Physical Security Lighting Security lighting should be provided for overall site and building illumination and the perimeter to allow security personnel to maintain visual assessment during darkness. Lighting is desirable around areas such as piers, fence lines, dock, storage areas, and parking lots. At entry points, a minimum surface lighting average of 4 horizontal foot candles will help ensure adequate lighting is recommended. Site Utilities (1) Utility systems can suffer significant damage when subjected to the shock of an explosion. Some of these utilities may be critical for safely evacuating people from the building. Their destruction could cause damage that is disproportionate to other building damage resulting from an explosion. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY These are examples of protected utilities; however, some property has exposed natural water and gas lines that can easily be tampered with. A thorough walk-through of the site property should be conducted and proper protection devices should be applied to exposed utilities. VISUAL VIII-37 VISUAL VIII-38 Compare and contrast the CPTED principal of single-point visitor control versus the location and placement of parking structures next to buildings. Site Utilities (2) The U.S. utility infrastructure is highly concentrated, utilizing the same rights-of-way, tunnels, underground conduits, and other service points. Examine where the utilities intersect (manholes, poles, city blocks, etc.) to find critical nodes. Install fencing and if possible, remote monitoring capability at key electrical substations, pumping plants, and communications vaults. CPTED The application of CPTED principles starts with a threat and vulnerability analysis to determine the potential for attack and what needs to be protected. Protecting a building from physical attack by criminal behavior or terrorist activity, in many cases, only reflects a change in the level and types of threats. The CPTED process provides direction to solve the challenges of crime and terrorism with organizational (people), mechanical (technology and hardware), and natural design (architecture and circulation flow) methods. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY VISUAL VIII-39 Page 2-52 of FEMA 426 provides a comprehensive list of security/protection measures that can be taken - increasing in protection, cost, and level of effort - that complements this graphic on Site Mitigation Measures. VISUAL VIII-40 Refer participants to FEMA 426, the Unit VIII Case Study activity in the Student Manual, and the GIS portfolio. Members of the instructor staff should be available to answer questions and assist groups as needed. Summary To summarize: . Ą A broad spectrum of mitigation actions can be taken - with a wide range of cost, protection provided, and level of effort required by the asset owner. . Ą This nominal ranking of mitigation measures provides a framework for the identification of short-term and long-term measures that can be taken. Student Activity The Building Vulnerability Assessment Checklist in FEMA 426 can be used as a screening tool for preliminary design vulnerability assessment. The checklist includes questions that determine if critical systems will continue to function to enhance deterrence, detection, denial, and damage limitation, and if emergency systems will function during a threat or hazard situation. Activity Requirements . Ą Continue working in small groups. . Ą Assign sections of the checklist to the group member who is most knowledgeable and qualified to perform an assessment of the assigned area. . Ą Refer to the HIC Case Study and to the GIS portfolio to determine answers to the worksheet questions. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance INSTRUCTOR NOTES CONTENT/ACTIVITY At the end of 45 minutes, reconvene the class and facilitate group reporting. Ą Then review results to identify vulnerabilities and possible mitigation measures. Take 45 minutes to complete this activity. Solutions will be reviewed in plenary group. Transition Unit IX will cover Building Design Guidance. Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance UNIT VIII CASE STUDY ACTIVITY: SITE AND LAYOUT DESIGN GUIDANCE The Building Vulnerability Assessment Checklist in FEMA 426 can be used as a screening tool for preliminary design vulnerability assessment. The checklist includes questions that determine if critical systems will continue to function to enhance deterrence, detection, denial, and damage limitation, and emergency systems function during a threat or hazard situation. Requirement Assign sections of the checklist to the group member who is most knowledgeable and qualified to perform an assessment of the assigned area. Refer to the HIC Case Study and to the GIS portfolio to determine answers to the questions. Then review results to identify vulnerabilities and possible mitigation measures. 1. 1. Complete the following components of the Building Vulnerability Assessment Checklist, which address site and layout. 2. 2. Upon completion of these portions of the checklist, refer back to the site risk rating determined in Unit V Case Study Activity and, based on this detailed analysis, decide if the rating is accurate. 3. 3. Select mitigation measures to reduce vulnerability and associated risk from the site and layout perspective. 4. 4. Estimate the new risk ratings for high risk asset-threat pairs based on the recommended mitigation measures. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations 1.1 What major structures surround the facility (site or building(s))? Critical infrastructure to consider includes: Telecommunications infrastructure There are two Critical Hazard Facilities within 2 miles of the HIC Headquarters, one to the What critical Facilities for broadcast TV, cable TV; cellular networks; newspaper north and the other to the southwest. In addition, there infrastructure, government, military, or recreation facilities are in the local area that impact transportation, offices, production, and distribution; radio stations; satellite base stations; telephone trunking and switching stations, including critical cable routes and major rights-of-way are more than a dozen Tier II HAZMAT Facilities within 3 miles of the building (in all directions). A major interstate highway utilities, and collateral damage (attack at this facility impacting the other major structures or Electric power systems Power plants, especially nuclear facilities; transmission and distribution system components; fuel distribution, delivery, and is located within 1/4 mile of the HIC Headquarters. CSX Transportation and Norfolk-Southern Railway Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Unit VIII: Site and Layout Design Guidance Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations attack on the major structures impacting this facility)? storage Gas and oil facilities Hazardous material facilities, oil/gas pipelines, and storage facilities Banking and finance institutions Financial institutions (banks, credit unions) and the business district; note schedule business/financial district may follow; armored car services Transportation networks Airports: carriers, flight paths, and airport layout; location of air traffic control towers, runways, passenger terminals, and parking areas Bus Stations: Pipelines: oil; gas Trains/Subways: rails and lines, railheads/rail yards, interchanges, tunnels, and cargo/passenger terminals; note hazardous material transported Traffic: interstate highways/roads/tunnels/ bridges carrying large volumes; points of congestion; note time of day and day of week Trucking: hazardous materials cargo loading/unloading facilities; truck terminals, weigh stations, and rest areas Waterways: dams; levees; berths and ports for cruise ships, ferries, roll-on/roll-off cargo vessels, and container ships; international (foreign) flagged vessels (and cargo) Water supply systems Pipelines and process/treatment facilities, dams for water collection; wastewater treatment Government services Federal/state/local government offices - post offices, law enforcement stations, fire/rescue, town/city hall, local mayor's/governor's residences, judicial offices and courts, military installations (include type-active, Reserves, National maintain a transportation corridor about 1/2 mile from HIC. There appear to be no restrictions on the material carried along these rail lines. A leg of the Piedmont Petroleum Pipeline (PPP) runs underneath the office park in the vicinity of HIC Headquarters. Part of Piedmont's regional network, this portion of the pipeline normally carries a variety of refined products, including commercial and military jet fuels, diesel and three grades of gasoline, home heating fuels, etc. Four buried pipes carry approximately 20 million gallons per day. Connected to the pipeline, less than 1 mile from HIC, is a 20-million gallon capacity fuel farm. Operated by the Shellexxico Company, this tank farm stores a variety of petroleum products, primarily gasoline. Two airports are in the vicinity of HIC. One is a major international airport approximately 8 miles away. The other is a small, but busy general aviation airport approximately 2 miles away. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations Guard) Emergency services Backup facilities, communications centers, Emergency Operations Centers (EOCs), fire/Emergency Medical Service (EMS) facilities, Emergency Medical Centers (EMCs), law enforcement facilities The following are not critical infrastructure, but have collateral damage potential to consider: Agricultural facilities: chemical distribution, storage, and application sites; crop spraying services; farms and ranches; food processing, storage, and distribution facilities Commercial/manufacturing/ind- ustrial facilities: apartment buildings; business/corporate centers; chemical plants (especially those with Section 302 Extremely Hazardous Substances); factories; fuel production, distribution, and storage facilities; hotels and convention centers; industrial plants; raw material production, distribution, and storage facilities; research facilities and laboratories; shipping, warehousing, transfer, and logistical centers Events and attractions: festivals and celebrations; open-air markets; parades; rallies, demonstrations, and marches; religious services; scenic tours; theme parks Health care system components: family planning clinics; health department offices; hospitals; radiological material and medical waste transportation, storage, and disposal; research facilities and laboratories, walk-in clinics Political or symbolically significant sites: embassies, consulates, landmarks, monuments, political party and Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations special interest groups offices, religious sites Public/private institutions: academic institutions, cultural centers, libraries, museums, research facilities and laboratories, schools Recreation facilities: auditoriums, casinos, concert halls and pavilions, parks, restaurants and clubs (frequented by potential target populations), sports arenas, stadiums, theaters, malls, and special interest group facilities; note congestion date and times for shopping centers References: FEMA 386-7, FEMA SLG 101, DOJ NCJ181200 1.2 Does the terrain place the building in a depression or low area? Depressions or low areas can trap heavy vapors, inhibit natural decontamination by prevailing winds, and reduce the effectiveness of in-place sheltering. Reference: USAF Installation Force Protection Guide The site is above the tank farm and the rear parking area slopes away from the building to a stream, which allows winds to pass over the structure unhindered. 1.3 In dense, urban areas, does curb lane parking place uncontrolled parked vehicles unacceptably close to a building in public rights-of-way? Where distance from the building to the nearest curb provides insufficient setback, restrict parking in the curb lane. For typical city streets, this may require negotiating to close the curb lane. Setback is common terminology for the distance between a building and its associated roadway or parking. It is analogous to stand-off between a vehicle bomb and the building. The benefit per foot of increased stand-off between a potential vehicle bomb and a building is very high when close to a building and decreases rapidly as the distance increases. Note that the July 1, 1994, Americans with Disabilities Act Standards for Accessible Design states that required handicapped parking shall be located on the shortest accessible route of travel from adjacent parking to an accessible With a loading dock on the west side, it is possible for vehicles to park right next to the building. Normal parking for employees is in front; the closest row is 44 feet from the front door. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations entrance. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 1.4 Is a perimeter fence or other types of barrier controls in place? The intent is to channel pedestrian traffic onto a site with multiple buildings through known access control points. For a single building, the intent is to have a single visitor entrance. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 There is no fence or other type of barrier on the site's perimeter. 1.5 What are the site access points to the site or building? The goal is to have at least two access points - one for passenger vehicles and one for delivery trucks due to the different procedures needed for each. Having two access points also helps if one of the access points becomes unusable, then traffic can be routed through the other access point. Reference: USAF Installation Force Protection Guide Loading dock on the west side of the building and front entrance with an 8-foot overhang. Additional exits (including mezzanine exits): 4. 1.6 Is vehicle traffic separated from pedestrian traffic on the site? Pedestrian access should not be endangered by car traffic. Pedestrian access, especially from public transportation, should not cross vehicle traffic if possible. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 and FEMA 386-7 Sidewalks at the front of the building allow access to the site without pedestrian/ vehicle interface. However, pedestrians must negotiate the parking lot to access the sidewalk. 1.7 Is there vehicle and pedestrian access control at the perimeter of the site? Vehicle and pedestrian access control and inspection should occur as far from facilities as possible (preferably at the site perimeter) with the ability to regulate the flow of people and vehicles one at a time. Control on-site parking with identification checks, security personnel, and access control systems. Reference: FEMA 386-7 There is no access control to the site; however, security personnel monitor parking areas, and rear parking areas are well lit and monitored by CCTC cameras; front parking areas are lit only. Area proximity card prevent access by unauthorized personnel. 1.8 Is there space for inspection at the curb line or outside the protected perimeter? What is the minimum distance from the inspection location to the building? Design features for the vehicular inspection point include: vehicle arrest devices that prevent vehicles from leaving the vehicular inspection area and prevent tailgating. If screening space cannot be provided, consider other design features such as: hardening and alternative location for vehicle The building has no protected perimeter; however, there is adequate space in the rear parking area to conduct truck pre-screening away from the building. 44 feet from first parking space to the building. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations search/ inspection. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 1.9 Is there any potential access to the site or building through utility paths or water runoff? Eliminate potential site access through utility tunnels, corridors, manholes, stormwater runoff culverts, etc. Ensure covers to these access points are secured. Reference: USAF Installation Force Protection Guide Unknown without a more detailed on-site assessment. 1.10 What are the existing types of vehicle anti-ram devices for the site or building? Are these devices at the property boundary or at the building? Passive barriers include bollards, walls, hardened fences (steel cable interlaced), trenches, ponds/basins, concrete planters, street furniture, plantings, trees, sculptures, and fountains. Active barriers include pop-up bollards, swing arm gates, and rotating plates and drums, etc. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 There are no anti-ram barriers at the site. 1.11 What is the anti-ram buffer zone stand-off distance from the building to unscreened vehicles or parking? If the recommended distance for the postulated threat is not available, consider reducing the stand-off required through structural hardening or manufacturing additional stand-off through barriers and parking restrictions. Also consider relocation of vulnerable functions within the building or to a more hazard-resistant building. More stand-off should be used for unscreened vehicles than for screened vehicles that are searched. Reference: GSA PBS P-100 There are no anti-ram barriers at the site. 1.12 Are perimeter barriers capable of stopping vehicles? Will the vehicle barriers at the perimeter and building maintain access for emergency responders, including large fire apparatus? Anti-ram protection may be provided by adequately designed: bollards, street furniture, sculpture, landscaping, walls, and fences. The anti-ram protection must be able to stop the threat vehicle size (weight) at the speed attainable by that vehicle at impact. If the anti-ram protection cannot absorb the desired kinetic energy, consider adding speed controls (serpentines or speed bumps) to limit the speed at impact. If the resultant speed is still too great, the anti-ram protection should be improved. There are no anti-ram barriers at the site. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations Reference: Military Handbook 1013/14 and GSA PBS P-100 1.13 Does site circulation prevent high-speed approaches by vehicles? The intent is to use site circulation to minimize vehicle speeds and eliminate direct approaches to structures. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 No, from the main road, there is a parking entrance road that leads directly to the center of the building complex. A vehicle could easily reach 30-40 mph. 1.14 Are there offsetting vehicle entrances from the direction of a vehicle's approach to force a reduction of speed? Single or double 90-degree turns effectively reduce vehicle approach speed. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 Yes. Closing the gap between the last landscape area would eliminate the straightaway. 1.15 Is there a minimum setback distance between the building and parked vehicles? Adjacent public parking should be directed to more distant or better-protected areas, segregated from employee parking and away from the building. Some publications use the term setback in lieu of the term stand-off. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 It is possible for vehicles to park right next to the building near the loading dock. Normal parking for employees is in front; the closest row is 44 feet from the front door. 1.16 Does adjacent surface parking on site maintain a minimum stand-off distance? The specific stand-off distance needed is based upon the design basis threat bomb size and the building construction. For initial screening, consider using 25 meters (82 feet) as a minimum with more distance needed for unreinforced masonry or wooden walls. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 No. minimum stand-off of 44 feet at this location. 1.17 Do stand alone, aboveground parking garages provide adequate visibility across as well as into and out of the parking garage? Pedestrian paths should be planned to concentrate activity to the extent possible. Limiting vehicular entry/exits to a minimum number of locations is beneficial. Stair tower and elevator lobby design shall be as open as code permits. Stair and/or elevator waiting areas should be as open to the exterior and/or the parking areas as possible and well lighted. Impact-resistant, laminated glass for stair towers and elevators is a way to provide visual openness. Potential hiding places below No above-ground parking garages exist on site. However the open, ground-level parking provides adequate visibility across the lot. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations stairs should be closed off; nooks and crannies should be avoided, and dead-end parking areas should be eliminated. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 1.18 Are garage or service area entrances for employee-permitted vehicles protected by suitable anti-ram devices? Coordinate this protection with other anti-ram devices, such as on the perimeter or property boundary to avoid duplication of arresting capability. Control internal building parking, underground parking garages, and access to service areas and loading docks in this manner with proper access control or eliminate the parking altogether. The anti-ram device must be capable of arresting a vehicle of the designated threat size at the speed attainable at the location. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 No above-ground parking garages exist on site. 1.19 Do site landscaping and street furniture provide hiding places? Minimize concealment opportunities by keeping landscape plantings (hedges, shrubbery, and large plants with heavy ground cover) and street furniture (bus shelters, benches, trash receptacles, mailboxes, newspaper vending machines) away from the building to permit observation of intruders and prevent hiding of packages. If mail or express boxes are used, the size of the openings should be restricted to prohibit the insertion of packages. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 Minimal landscaping and the layout of the property provide few if any hiding places. 1.20 Is the site lighting adequate from a security perspective in roadway access and parking areas? Security protection can be successfully addressed through adequate lighting. The type and design of lighting, including illumination levels, is critical. Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) guidelines can be used. The site lighting should be coordinated with the CCTV system. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 Both rear and front parking areas are well lit. Rear areas are also monitored by CCTC cameras. 1.21 Are line-of-sight The goal is to prevent the observation of critical assets by No. There are clear approximately 300 foot lines Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations perspectives from outside the secured boundary to the building and on the property along pedestrian and vehicle routes integrated with landscaping and green space? persons outside the secure boundary of the site. For individual buildings in an urban environment, this could mean appropriate window treatments or no windows for portions of the building. Once on the site, the concern is to ensure observation by a general workforce aware of any pedestrians and vehicles outside normal circulation routes or attempting to approach the building unobserved. Reference: USAF Installation Force Protection Guide of sight in all directions. 1.22 Do signs provide control of vehicles and people? The signage should be simple and have the necessary level of clarity. However, signs that identify sensitive areas should generally not be provided. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 There are no parking lots signs. 1.23 Are all existing fire hydrants on the site accessible? Just as vehicle access points to the site must be able to transit emergency vehicles, so too must the emergency vehicles have access to the buildings and, in the case of fire trucks, the fire hydrants. Thus, security considerations must accommodate emergency response requirements. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 Yes. 2 Architectural 2.1 Does the site and architectural design incorporate strategies from a Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) perspective? The focus of CPTED is on creating defensible space by employing: 1. Natural access controls: Design streets, sidewalks, and building entrances to clearly indicate public routes and direct people away from private/restricted areas Discourage access to private areas with structural elements and limit access (no cut-through streets) Loading zones should be separate from public parking 2. Natural surveillance: Design that maximizes visibility of people, parking areas, and building entrances: doors and Site design clearly directs visitors to the front of the building and to clearly marked entrances. Loading areas are separate from public parking. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations windows that look out on to streets and parking areas Shrubbery under 2 feet in height for visibility Lower branches of existing trees kept at least 10 feet off ground Pedestrian-friendly sidewalks and streets to control pedestrian and vehicle circulation Adequate nighttime lighting, especially at exterior doorways 3. Territorial reinforcement: Design that defines property lines Design that distinguishes private/restricted spaces from public spaces using separation, landscape plantings; pavement designs (pathway and roadway placement); gateway treatments at lobbies, corridors, and door placement; walls, barriers, signage, lighting, and "CPTED" fences "Traffic-calming" devices for vehicle speed control 4. Target hardening: Prohibit entry or access: window locks, deadbolts for doors, interior door hinges Access control (building and employee/visitor parking) and intrusion detection systems 5. Closed circuit television cameras: Prevent crime and influence positive behavior, while enhancing the intended uses of space. In other words, design that eliminates or reduces criminal behavior and at the same time encourages people to "keep an eye out" for each other. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 and FEMA 386-7 2.2 Is it a mixed-tenant building? Separate high-risk tenants from low-risk tenants and from publicly accessible areas. Mixed uses may The building site is a multiple-tenant facility; HIC has neighbors on both sides. be accommodated through such In addition to other tenants means as separating entryways, in the building, the site also controlling access, and hardening contains multiple buildings shared partitions, as well as through special security in the same professional park. Section Vulnerability Questions Guidance Observations operational countermeasures. Reference: GSA PBS-P100 2.3 Are pedestrian paths planned to concentrate activity to aid in detection? Site planning and landscape design can provide natural surveillance by concentrating pedestrian activity, limiting entrances/exits, and eliminating